HOME
 
ON-LINE MOTORING BOOKSHOP
Cars & 4WDs
Motorcycles
Tractors
Boats
DVDs
Motor Sport
Books by Subject
 
AUTOMOTIVE
NEWS
SERVICE
Road Tests
Used Car Reviews
News
Historic Cars
Opinion
Motorcycle
Tests
Boat Tests
 
MARQUE
AUTOMOTIVE
ARCHIVES
Sales Brochures
Photographs
Press Kits
Other Items
 
LINKS

marque.com.au
AUTOMOTIVE NEWS SERVICE
ROAD TEST


HOLDEN'S ENGINES A FUEL SAVER

By EWAN KENNEDY
6 November 2006


Holden’s new Astra turbo-diesel is an important model in the Holden lineup. Because it shows the local company is keeping in touch with the swing to diesel fuel in other countries. Europeans are buying diesel cars in ever-increasing numbers due to the uncertainty of fuel prices in recent times.

Though Australian fuel remains cheap in comparison with that in Europe, the sudden rises over the last year have turned buyers’ minds towards diesel cars. It’s not just saving money they have in mind, the latest generation of turbo-diesel engines is also offering strong performance. And those who care about problems being created by global warming realise that diesels have lower emission levels that petrols.

Holden's new diesel engines come from its Euro partner Opel. Two different diesels are offered: a twin-cam unit of 1.9 litres that is used exclusively with a sporting six-speed manual gearbox. It produces 110 kilowatts, and 320 Newton metres at 2000 rpm. This is priced at $29,990 plus on-road costs.

The other engine has the same 1.9-litre capacity but uses a simpler single-cam design so its power peak is only 88 kW and top torque is 280 Nm, between 2000 rpm and 2750 rpm. This engine is mated to a sophisticated six-speed automatic transmission and has been selected by Holden in order to keep the car’s price down to $31,490.

Thus the price premium for the Astra diesel automatic is only $1500. Had the more expensive engine been mated to this transmission the chances are the auto option would have been about $2500 higher, perhaps even $3000.

Which makes a lot of sense because the person buying an engine to cut running costs isn’t prepared to pay a big premium to do so.

The Astra CDTi turbo-diesel we road tested was the six-speed manual. In equipment levels it is virtually identical to the upmarket petrol Astra CDX. It features climate-controlled air conditioning, alloy wheels, front foglamps, a leather-wrapped steering wheel and cruise control. Safety items included ABS brakes, an electronic stability program and six airbags.

Only at idle is the engine obviously a diesel, with that distinctive clatter. It’s not obtrusive from inside the car, but your neighbours will have no doubt you are an early adopter in the turbo-diesel race. In steady state running, noise and vibration levels are almost as low as those of a petrol Astra.

The new Astra CDTi engine has some turbo lag but it’s not too bad. Once everything has got itself up to speed inside the engine there's an excellent amount of torque. Overtaking is simple if you anticipate on the need for torque and get onto the accelerator about a second before you move out to pass. Give it a try for yourself if you haven’t driven a turbo-diesel before to get a feel for what it’s all about. Most drivers adapt to the technique easily and it soon becomes second nature.

The fuel efficiency of diesel engines is well known and most people will only use six to seven litres per hundred kilometres in moderate country and motorway driving. That will rise to about eight to nine litres per hundred in suburban use, which is still pretty economical.

Though we haven’t done a full test on an automatic Astra diesel, it’s officially measured fuel figure is 7.4 litres per hundred kilometres, compared with the manual’s 6.0 litres per hundred. We wouldn’t expect such a big percentage difference in day-to-day running, but can’t comment correctly at this stage.

But there's more to the new Astra CDTi than simply its diesel engine. Styling is a major selling feature of this car, with its neat frontal treatment and detailed touches that give it an upmarket European flavour. The roof slopes sharply to the rear to improve high-speed aerodynamics, yet this doesn’t adversely affect rear seat headroom.

Moving the front seats forward a few notches on their runners still leaves a decent amount of legroom and means the Astra can be used as a full four-seater for adults. Five occupants are only going to be comfortable if at least two in the back are children. Front seat space is fine thanks to the space-saving front-wheel drive.

Handling is everything you would expect from a small-medium European car. Those who like their cars will love the way the Holden Astra holds to the road with a minimum of fuss. It answers commands to the steering wheel promptly and efficiently. There may be some additional understeer if you really hustle the turbo-diesel along, due to the extra weight in the front of the car. But short of a back-to-back test it’s certainly not obvious.

Is the extra cost of a diesel engine worth it? At this time diesel fuel in Australia is about 15 to 25 per cent more expensive than petrol, so the typically lower fuel usage of about 30 to 35 per cent is partly negated.

There's no reason to believe that depreciation on diesels will be any higher (or lower) than that on petrols. Glass's Guide figures are suggesting they will be much the same, though it’s still relatively early days for diesel cars in Australia.

AT A GLANCE

MODEL RANGE
CD 1.8-litre five-door hatch - $21,990

CDX 1.8-litre five-door hatch - $24,490

CDXi 1.8-litre five-door hatch - $28,990
CD Coupe 1.8-litre three-door hatch - $23,990
CDX Coupe 1.8-litre three-door hatch - $26,990
CD 1.8-litre five-door wagon - $23,790
CDX 1.8-litre five-door wagon - $26,490
CDTi 1.9-litre diesel five-door hatch - $29,990
CDTi 1.9-litre diesel five-door hatch - $31,490

SRi 2.0-litre turbo three-door hatch - $34,990

FEATURES
ABS Brakes: Standard in all models
Air Conditioning: Standard in all models
Automatic Transmission: Not offered in SRi, standard in all models
CD Player: Standard in all models
Central Locking: Standard in all models
Cruise Control: Not offered in CD, standard in all other models
Driver Airbag: Standard in all models
Passenger Airbag: Standard in all models
Front Side Airbags: Standard in all models

SPECIFICATIONS (Holden Astra CDTi 1.9-litre diesel manual five-door hatch)

ENGINE:
Capacity: 1.910 litres
Configuration: Transverse, four cylinders in line
Head Design: DOHC, four valves per cylinder
Compression Ratio: 17.5:1
Bore/Stroke: 82.0 x 90.4mm
Maximum Power: 110kW @ 4000rpm
Maximum Torque: 320Nm @ 2000-2750rpm

DRIVELINE:
Driven Wheels: Front
Manual Transmission: Six-speed
Automatic Transmission: Not offered
Final Drive Ratio: 3.65:1

DIMENSIONS, WEIGHT AND CAPACITIES:
Length: 4249mm
Wheelbase: 2614mm
Width: 1753mm
Height: 1460mm
Turning Circle: 10.6 metres

Kerb Mass: 1372kg
Fuel Tank Capacity: 52 litres
Towing Ability: 630kg (1300kg with braked trailer)

MECHANICAL SPECIFICATIONS:
Front Suspension: Independent, MacPherson struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar
Rear Suspension: Compound torsion beam, twin trailing arms, coil springs, anti-roll bar
Front Brakes: Ventilated disc
Rear Brakes: Disc

PERFORMANCE:
0-100 km/h Acceleration: NA
Standing 400 Metres: NA

FUEL CONSUMPTION:
Fuel Type: Diesel
Fuel Consumption - Combined Cycle (ADR 81/01): 6.0 L/100km

STANDARD WARRANTY:
Three years/100,000km

© Copyright Marque Publishing Company